Alice in Gardenland

I started this post a while back following a a visit to Christ Church for the Gardens Trust conference in Oxford in September 2019.  The visit had special significance for the Gardens Trust because Christ Church was once home to Mavis Batey the driving force behind the foundation of the Garden History Society – now part of the Gardens Trust -way back in 1966.  Her husband Keith was the Treasurer of Christ Church and she obviously fell in love with the city and Christ Church in particular.

Amongst her many other achievements, including being one of the leading codebreakers at Bletchley Park,  she also wrote about the most well-known literary figure associated with the college and the city: Alice Liddell, who was the inspiration behind Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland and Alice through the Looking Glass.

I got so far with my research and then it slipped down the agenda until recently when I saw that the V&A were planning an exhibition about Alice which was supposed to open next week but luckily is scheduled to run until Christmas.  So that was a good excuse to go back and look again at the world of Alice in Gardenland….

Oxford colleges always appear  from the streets outside to be densely packed with buildings with very little green space, although the game is sometimes given away by the  occasional glimpse of lawn as one peers in past the porters lodge.  Our visit to Christ Church proved just how deceptive that idea is. Behind its walls “the House”, as it is often known, has a whole series of gardens and green spaces,  public, semi-public and private, many of which are invisible even when through the gates and wandering around.

Christ Church and its meadow. The city centre is at the top of the image, with the crossroads of Carfax on the left and the Botanic Gardens and Magdalen Bridge too right. The Great Quad is clearly visible towards the top left.

Founded as Cardinal College by Cardinal Wolsey in 1525  Christ Church lies partly inside the line of the mediaeval city walls and partly without. Wolsey had suppressed St Frideswide’s Priory the previous  year and taken over its buildings for his new institution, the priory church becoming the college chapel.  Building work was still underway when he fell from power in 1529.  The project was taken over rather half-heartedly by Henry VIII, and refounded with  the former priory church becoming the city’s cathedral, with, uniquely, the Dean running both cathedral and college.  Outside the walls the grounds extend through the meadows to the south all the way to the Thames covering about 32ha. Most of the college buildings are on the National Heritage List for England at Grade 1 while most of the grounds and landscape are  included on Historic England’s Register of Historic Parks and Gardens  also at  the highest level, Grade 1.

The most public of the college landscapes is the Meadow which was given to the priory in 1346 and is maintained today as freely accessible open space.  Originally it was two distinct meadows divided by a now virtually dried up lake, visible because of the ditch that still runs across the fields.  The two fields  are home to Christ Church’s herd of  Old English Longhorn cattle and are managed without the use of chemicals or fertilisers.

Over the centuries the Meadow has played a major role in flood prevention, acting as a giant sponge when the rivers breach their banks and overflow. This is  not a common occurrence, although it did happen in February this year,  and  shows the environmental importance of such water meadows in preventing much wider damage downstream.  They flood quickly but as the water levels recede the meadows release the water back at a much slower rate. John James, the head gardener at Christ Church who has the Meadow in his jurisdiction published spectacular photos  on his blog of the recent  flooding, with paths knee deep under waters, deer stranded and even a few trees brought down.

He is also overseeing a more active management system for the meadows which will involve restoring many native species of wildflowers as part of a much larger project -the Thames Valley Wildflower Meadow Restoration Project. Such floodplain meadows are incredibly rare with only 4 square miles remaining in the entire country, with many of them designated as Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) or Local Wildlife Sites on the upper reaches of the Thames. Building on the success of Natural England’s Agri-Environment schemes which have been running in some of the affected areas for a couple of decades farmers and landowners are working in partnership with academics in an attempt to halt the catastrophic decline in biodiversity by  linking  up these small sites  and recreating similar habitats where it has been lost.

Given all that it might be assumed that Christ Church Meadow is a natural phenomenon. In fact much of its appearance is man-made with the first recorded intervention being  in the 1570s. Then a perimeter walk of a double or even quadruple row of trees was planted around most of the boundaries and along the river with  the area named on a map of 1578 as ‘Christ Church Meadows and Walkes’.  There was a similar walk around nearby Magdalen Meadow too. These predate the more formal “urban” walks at Moorfields in London which were started in 1606, and at Gray’s Inn which date to 1608

During the Civil War when Christ Church  served as the headquarters of Charles I, the meadows were deliberately flooded  and earthwork fortifications were constructed as additional protection.  After the Restoration the walk along the northern side was replanted with closely spaced elms and the surface ” improved” using the spoil from the lowering of the surface level in the college’s Great Quad which  may have given rise to its nickname of the White Walk, although it is properly known as the Broad Walk.

In the 19thc Henry Liddell, father of Alice, who was Dean for nearly 40 years, laid out the New Walk.  This was raised up  like a causeway and ran from the then new Venetian Gothic-style Meadow Building of the college to the  Isis or Thames, and its thought was planted with a mix of elm and lime.

The Meadow Building built between 1862-1865

At the same time Dean Liddell  also  extended the Broad Walk   by arranging the planting of specimen trees by a range of dignitaries and his own family, including Alice.   These became popular promenades for both town and gown.

On the Cherwell, Christ Church in Distance,   Broad Walk on the left,  after 1879, Birket Foster

Unfortunately in the 20thc as everywhere else  Oxford was threatened by two scourges.

Traffic was the first.  The saga began in 1960 when Oxford City Council asked the Government to conduct a public inquiry into Oxford’s traffic problems, which found a road across the meadow was “inescapable”.  It was proposed to flatten over 150 houses, divert the Cherwell and build a road across the Meadow, in a cutting  nearly 6m deep.

Unsurprisingly The Oxford Preservation Trust warned of “irreparable damage” while  Christ Church called the plan “repugnant and offensive”.  A public enquiry in 1965 led to the scheme being “reviewed” then dropped in favour of a relief road further out. That too met with fierce opposition and was eventually dropped. The scariest part of the story is the plans were drawn up by the great landscape architect Geoffrey Jellicoe.

On a positive note it was the controversy behind this scheme that helped establish the Garden History Society, and also gave Oxford the distinction of establishing the first park-and-ride system in the country.

The Poplar Walk, Thomas Taylor 1803

The other problem was Dutch Elm disease which ravaged the walks in the 1970s and meant that in 1975 they had to be felled and replanted. The choice was made then to use  more widely spaced London and Oriental planes on the Broad Walk but this significantly altered its character and so more recently however it has been decided to adopt a longer term management strategy  where disease resistant elms will be  re-introduced to the Broad Walk to restore the original planting intention.

None of Dean Liddell’s original planting on the New Walk survives, indeed it was replanted only some 60 years later in the 1920s with Black Poplars,  with some Balsam Poplars  added in the 1970s and a selection of lime species at other times. While poplars are highly tolerant of the damp and sometimes even waterlogged conditions they are also short-lived and relatively unstable, which does not make them good long term choice for public spaces.  Indeed many of the century-old poplars are beginning to decay and drop branches without any forewarning signs and so in 2015 the first group were felled and replaced with  common lime. More will undoubtedly  follow.

St Aldates [the main road] on the left and the beginning of the Broad Walk on the right

At the western end of the Broad Walk is the other  easily visible part of the grounds: the War Memorial Garden, which it’s estimated is seen by more than a million people annually.   This was designed almost a century ago by the brothers John and Paul Coleridge and built on the site of a demolished building which also opened views across into the college.

the entrance to the Broad Walk with the War Memorial Garden on both sides as far as which lies on both sides of the path as far as the people in the distance. From Google Earth.

It is not a single unified garden but has several sections on either side of a long York-stone path.  On the right was an area of grass with what were supposed to be pleached lime trees, but which have been allowed to grow naturally.  On the left was an irregular area shaped like a reversed L. The main feature here is a  long herbaceous border, raised up on a stone wall,   which according to the Head Gardener is  now “planted to maximise interest throughout the year using restful colours and plants with winter interest.”   Unfortunately  it can only be reviewed through railings, to prevent invasion by the hordes of visitors, although Tim Richardson argues this  “only adds to the romance.”

At the far end, just as the Broad Walk widens out, the Coleridges  designed a more formal pair of small gardens to fill another irregular space.

On the south side is what is still known as the “Rose Garden”, despite only containing one rose, was originally planned as a Dutch Garden but was actually built as an iris garden. It is bright and colourful and unusually, compared with the rest of the college grounds, is normally filled with seasonal bedding displays  grown in-house.

This year the Head Gardeners blog showed how they had had to cope during the pandemic with  no gardeners on site for several months  and how instead of bedding he had used an exotic “cornfield” mix.

Now lets move inside…

Inside the college precincts things are very different.  There are two monumental quads and a series of more human-scale intimate spaces.

Tom Quad

 

The Great Quad or Tom Quad which, at 80m square, is the largest quad in Oxford, was started but not finished  by Wolsey with  the arches of his proposed cloister are clearly visible. Other than some alterations to the layout of the paths and terraces in the late 1800s, little else has changed. It is simply  large areas of grass divided by paths, around  a lily pool with a copy of Giambologna’s Mercury installed by Lutyens in 1928. However it is not universally popular  with Tim Richardson, arguing it suffers from from “overbearing grandiloquence”.

 

Peckwater Quad

The other set-piece is Peckwater Quad built in the early 18thc. It  was said Ruskin who loved the Meadow Building “dull [but] all very grand” in a rather sterile Ionic style.  The central area there  too is merely filled with grass shapes although this time to an unexecuted design from 1733.

The Pococke Garden

 

 

 

 

On the other side of the cathedral which sits in the middle of the site, is a garden named after Edward Pococke who was professor of Hebrew at the university for almost the entire second half of the 17thc.      He had previously been chaplain to the Levant Company  in Aleppo in Syria     for over 5 years and bought back seeds of various trees. It is thought that the venerable oriental plane tree growing here was planted by him, and  is the oldest in the country.   Gnarled and twisted, with propped branches, it  has a girth of around nine metres.

Like everything else even slightly unusual in the garden it has an Alice/Lewis Carrol connection and may well be the inspiration for the Tumtum tree in  Jabberwocky poem.   The Pococke garden is an irregular shape and one of its boundaries  is the ancient city wall. As it is very sheltered the head gardener John James has created a garden full of  exotics including bananas, trachycarpus and tetrapanax. Last year his blog reported that passion fruit, palm fruit  and even pomegranates had set fruit here and in other parts of the garden.

The last of the major gardens is called the master’s Garden, though Christ Church has no master, and has well planted herbaceous borders around a central lawn. It appears from 18thc maps to have been a long established garden, although probably used earlier as a kitchen garden and orchard. Its current layout and use as a private space for students dates back about a century.

 

The houses of the cathedrals canons are dotted around the precincts and obviously are private but there are some nice images of them in the past.

But it’s the private Deanery Garden, and to a lesser extent the Cathedral Garden, that was the scene of most of the Alice-related stories  and for that I’m afraid we’ll have to wait until next week!

For more information take a look at the Church Church website and/or Tim Richardson’s Oxford College Gardens.

About The Gardens Trust

Email - education@thegardenstrust.org Website - www.thegardenstrust.org
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Alice in Gardenland

  1. John James says:

    What a great surprise to find this in my inbox this morning. Great article and very informative, I can see a lot of thought and research has gone into it. Thank you for the links to my blogs, that should generate some extra interest in the website hopefully.

    I’d love to post a link to the article on my gardens Instagram account @christchurchgardener if thats ok? I’m sure many of my followers would be interested in this great introduction to Christ Church.

    Thanks again and best wishes,

    John James

    Head Gardener

    Christ Church Gardens Dept

    St Aldates

    Oxford

    OX1 1DP

    07515 918511

    john.james@chch.ox.ac.uk

    Christ Church is committed to protecting the personal data of our students, staff, and visitors. For more information, please see our general Privacy Policy.

    Registered Charity Number: 1143423

    ________________________________

    • Dear John, Many thanks for the nice comments. I’m now feeling rather guilty because having spoken to you and Sarah Couch on that visit I ought to have checked with you – and failed to do so. My apologies, but obviously I’d be delighted if you want to tell other people about it. Knowing that you might read the follow-up is also a bit nerve-wracking! I hope I manage to do it justice. David

Leave a Reply to John James Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.